Monday 7 May 2007

What's your most overrated book of all time?

Just out of interest. You know what I mean: everyone loves it, or it's a classic and you think you will love it but it turns out to be pants...

9 comments:

Lindsay said...

I have a unnatural and undisguised hatred for Malcolm Lowry's Under the Volcano. He was an alco who lived in a trailer park and boy, did it show in his writing. But I shall have to think on that one..

my name is kate said...

I think The Book Thief is super overrated. It's a good story and an interesting idea but MAN is it pretentious.

Bolton said...

I think it is obvious that the Da Vinci Code is the most over-rated book of all time.

shiny said...

I really liked the book theif. I've never been interested in Jane Austen at all - at all. I also agree with Dan and think that Dan Brown should indeed be killed in the most painful and horrible way for polluting the world with that crap.

my name is kate said...

Yeah my sister loved,loved The Book Thief but I just sort of enjoyed the read but was distracted by what I didn't like about the language. I don't know why it is. I'm a real fan of less-is-more prose along the lines of Hemmingway so sometimes I get frustrated when I feel like the author has the pen in one hand and is wanking with the other.

shiny said...

No I love richer language. Although I probably won't anymore now I have a visual of Zusak wanking.
Because I like rich language I get irritated with people like Alexander Macall Smith. I would call him over-rated

Anonymous said...

Zusak is cute. I saw him in the comedy debate at the Perth Festival.
I'd watch him wanking. LOL

my name is kate said...

I think a lot of Alexander Macall Smith's stuff is patronising but strangely I do quite enjoy his books every once in awhile.

Zusak may be cute but at the talk he gave at the Perth library he said he likes to put a "little gem" on each page (ie: a turn of phrase that he likes). Wanker. And not the romantic explosion kind.

shiny said...

I didn't mind No 44 Scotland Street so much, but it was like something I'd read when I couldn't be bothered reading. It's like a mills n boon for the literary minded.

oops. Sorry kate, was that a "gem" a la Zusak? lol